By Frederick Schauer

Many criminal theorists hold that legislation are potent simply because we internalize them, obeying even if now not pressured to take action. In a entire reassessment of the position of strength in legislations, Frederick Schauer disagrees, demonstrating that coercion, greater than internalized pondering and behaving, distinguishes legislation from society’s different rules.

Reinvigorating rules from Jeremy Bentham and John Austin, and drawing on empirical examine in addition to philosophical research, Schauer offers an account of felony compliance in response to sanction and compulsion, exhibiting that law’s effectiveness relies essentially on its coercive capability. legislations, briefly, is set telling humans what to do and dangerous them with undesirable effects in the event that they fail to conform. even though humans may possibly occasionally obey the legislations out of deference to criminal authority instead of worry of sanctions, Schauer demanding situations the idea that criminal coercion is marginal in society. strength is extra pervasive than the state’s efforts to manage a minority of disobedient voters. while humans think that what they need to do differs from what the legislations instructions, compliance is much less universal than assumed, and the need of coercion turns into apparent.

Challenging winning modes of jurisprudential inquiry, Schauer makes transparent that the query of felony strength has sociological, mental, political, and fiscal dimensions that go beyond in simple terms conceptual issues. Grappling with the criminal system’s dependence on strength is helping us comprehend what legislation is, the way it operates, and the way it is helping set up society.

Show description

Read or Download The force of law PDF

Similar legal history books

Early Greek Law

Drawing at the proof of anthropology in addition to old literature and inscriptions, Gagarin examines the emergence of legislation in Greece from the eighth in the course of the sixth centuries B. C. , that's, from the oral tradition of Homer and Hesiod to the written enactment of codes of legislation in so much significant towns.

Kings, Barons and Justices: The Making and Enforcement of Legislation in Thirteenth-Century England

This ebook includes a research of 2 very important and similar items of thirteenth-century English legislation--the Provisions of Westminster of 1259 and the Statute of Marlborough of 1267. In constructing the political and criminal context of those statutes and analyzing the method of drafting them, the amount makes use of a very wide selection of manuscript assets.

Civil society in China : the legal framework from ancient times to the new reform era

This is often the definitive booklet at the criminal and monetary framework for civil society agencies (CSOs) in China from earliest occasions to the current day. Civil Society in China strains the ways that legislation and laws have formed civil society over the 5,000 years of China's heritage and appears at ways that social and fiscal historical past have affected the criminal alterations that experience happened over the millennia.

Jury, State, and Society in Medieval England

This booklet portrays the good number of paintings that medieval English juries performed whereas highlighting the dramatic elevate in calls for for jury provider that happened in this interval.

Extra info for The force of law

Sample text

But Hart took these criticisms further. He not only reemphasized that coercion seems not to explain the legal status of contracts, wills, trusts, and other optional features of law, but he also explored a topic noted only briefly by Pound and Allen: the role of law in constituting such arrangements in the first place. 21 Regulative rules, the most familiar sort of rule, govern conduct whose conceptual existence is logically prior to the rules. 22 This is also true of a person’s ability to bring about the death of another.

As with most attempts to understand texts from earlier times, it is important to appreciate the position an author was arguing against. And in this case, Austin’s foil, as it had been for Bentham, was to a significant extent William Blackstone narrowly and the overall natural law tradition more broadly. 45 Read with modern eyes, the last phrase might be understood as suggesting that the crime was in impugning the law’s validity, but that was not what Austin had in mind. Rather, he was insisting that a defendant’s view of the morality or justice of a law was largely beside the point.

Although he recognized that people could on occasion have purely social motives of benevolence and sympathy, and could even more often possess what he called the “semi-social” motivations to work for a common 13 14 T H E F O R C E O F L AW good from which they as individuals would proportionately benefit, Bentham believed that for most people most of the time—the “general rule,”26 as he put it—these social or semi-social motivations would be decidedly secondary to people’s self-regarding motivations—the desire to maximize their own well-being rather than that of others or that of the community as a whole.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.36 of 5 – based on 24 votes