By Megan Bishop Moore

Philosophy and perform in Writing a historical past of old Israel elucidates and examines assumptions approximately historical past writing that present historians of historical Israel and Judah hire. it's undertaken within the context of the clash among so-called "minimalists" and "maximalists" in the self-discipline at the present time. although using the Bible as proof is the focus of the competition of those techniques, Moore indicates variety of comparable philosophical and useful issues are telescoped during this factor, together with recommendations of Empiricism, Objectivity, illustration and Language, topic, rationalization, fact, and proof evaluate and Use. equipped round those issues, Philosophy and perform goals to situate the learn of historic Israel and Judah within the broader highbrow context of educational heritage regularly and to supply perception into the formative assumptions of the present debate. It additionally goals to teach that the valuable factor of the reliability of the Bible as proof is surrounded by means of similar matters which are both vital for figuring out the prior of historic Israel and Judah and writing approximately it. Moore exhibits that principles approximately objectivity specifically have an immediate touching on the evidentiary debate, which, in flip, impacts what matters and modes of motives historians see as on hand to them. Moore argues that present historians of historic Israel are starting to paintings with a thought of old fact that makes an attempt take into consideration the various contingencies for the concept that and writing of historical past that twentieth-century discussions approximately heritage have brought.

Show description

Read Online or Download Philosophy and Practice in Writing a History of Ancient Israel (The Library of Hebrew Bible - Old Testament Studies) PDF

Best israel & palestine books

Victory for Us Is to See You Suffer: In the West Bank with the Palestinians and the Israelis

Through the moment Palestinian intifada, Philip C. Winslow labored within the West financial institution with the United countries aid and Works employer (UNRWA), using as much as six hundred miles per week among virtually each Palestinian city, village, and refugee camp and each Israeli checkpoint within the occupied territory. He again previous to the onset of the 2006 warfare among Israel and Hizbollah in Lebanon.

Beyond Oslo, The Struggle for Palestine: Inside the Middle East Peace Process from Rabin's Death to Camp David

With new talks within the center East Peace technique approximately to start, the shadows of past negotiations fall seriously throughout all concerned. during this strong and soaking up testimony, one in every of major figures of the Oslo talks, former top Minister Ahmed Qurie (‘Abu Ala’) takes us in the back of closed doorways and contained in the negotiating rooms of Wye River, Stockholm and Camp David, the place the phrases of peace and a Palestinian country have been sketched out, argued over, and finally misplaced.

Despair and Deliverance: Private Salvation in Contemporary Israel

Booklet by means of Beit-Hallahmi, Benjamin

Extra info for Philosophy and Practice in Writing a History of Ancient Israel (The Library of Hebrew Bible - Old Testament Studies)

Example text

123. Chartier, On the Edge of the Cliff, 45. 124. J. L. Gorman, "Freedom and History" (review of C. Behan McCullagh, The Truth of History), History and Theory 39 (2000): 251-62 (251). 125. g. C. Behan McCullagh, Justifying Historical Descriptions (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984). 126. , The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy, 293-94 (293). 127. g. C. Behan McCullagh, "Metaphor and Truth in History," Clio 23 (1993): 24-49. 128. Richard L. , The Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 9:472-75 (472).

Paris: Armand Colin, 1966). Published in English as The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age of Philip II (New York: Harper & Row, 1972). 86. Braudel, The Mediterranean, 21. For a current discussion of history that involves placing human history in the context of universal and galactic history, see David Christian, Maps of Time: An Introduction to Big History (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2004). 87. Ferdinand de Saussure, Cours de linguistique generate (Lusanne: Payot, 1916).

Stanford appears to posit some relationship between intention and reliability when he suggests that historians should be skeptical of documents written for "other eyes," but does not clarify this theory any further. As will be seen below and in the remaining chapters of this study, some historians, including historians of ancient Israel, have addressed the relationship of a text's origin and intention to its reliability, and have attempted to formulate and apply theoretical principles to potential textual evidence for the past.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.48 of 5 – based on 48 votes